Lodge cast iron review: a modest claim, honestly made

There is something disarming about a $25 pan whose safety claim is boring. Lodge says its cookware is “made without PFAS”, which on bare cast iron is about as contestable as saying a brick contains no software.

That is the whole appeal, and it is why a skillet costing a fifth of the premium pans scores higher than most of them.

What they publish, point by point

Lodge Classic Cast Iron Skillet — 78/100 · mostly inert

$24.90 (10.25in)

• What touches the food — 42/60. Cast iron · seasoned with “100% natural vegetable oil”, species not named
• The rest of it — 25/25. Lids, seals, handles and the outside.
• Backed up — 11/15. A statutory materials filing, or named standards with a report number — a declaration rather than an independent test.
• Made in. USA — South Pittsburg, TN
• They claim. "Nontoxic cookware made without PFAS"
• Warranty. Limited lifetime, defects

One material, made in Tennessee, $25. The claim they make — “made without PFAS” on bare cast iron — is modest and obviously true, which is refreshing. Loses a composition point for the seasoning: “100% natural vegetable oil” is a category, not a named oil, and we dock other brands for exactly that.

What we’d want you to know:

• They do publish something. Lodge’s California AB 1200 disclosure lists the elements in seasoned cast iron — iron, phosphorus, manganese, strontium, plus carbon, silicon and sulfur — and a separate, longer list for the enamelled line including nickel, cadmium and chromium compounds. That is a statutory self-declaration against a designated chemical list, not third-party testing: no laboratory is named and no report is published, which is why it counts as a declaration rather than an independent test.
• No numeric oven or maximum heat guidance published anywhere we could find.
• The lifetime warranty is void if you put it in the dishwasher, soak it, or microwave it. It also excludes rust, pitting, sticky seasoning and flaking — which is most of what actually goes wrong with cast iron.

The full entry, with every source · The maker’s own page

Our verdict

The cheapest honest answer in the category. Cast iron is one material with no coating, so there is no recipe to withhold, and Lodge names the town it is made in.

We took a composition point for the seasoning. “100% natural vegetable oil” is a category, not an oil — and we dock other brands for exactly that kind of phrase, so we dock this one too. It is a small thing on a pan that is otherwise as legible as cookware gets.

Worth knowing before you buy: cast iron is heavy, needs drying, and is not the right pan for everything. Stainless is the easier everyday choice if you do not want to think about maintenance.

Related

• Solidteknics AUS-ION review
• Every pan, scored
• Made In cookware review
• What PFAS in cookware actually means